Ask Amy: Man welcomes daughter’s beau, but not his dog

Ask Amy: Man welcomes daughter’s beau, but not his dog

DEAR AMY: My 26-year-old daughter’s boyfriend just relocated to another city. Our daughter asked if he could travel the several hours to our home and stay with us over the holidays.

Amy Dickinson Amy Dickinson 

We welcome him. They have been dating for the past two years and this separation has been hard on her. The rub came when she announced his plans to bring his mid-size dog.

I told her that since we just moved into our new house (which has hardwood floors and Persian rugs in all the rooms) it wouldn’t be a good idea, and the potential for unnecessary damage is great. Any repairs could be awkward and costly. Even pawing at a closed door would damage the finish.

My daughter says the dog is very well-behaved and they will watch it closely when they are here; however, they plan on leaving the house to visit friends and during those periods we would have to be in charge.

We had a small dog for the last 17 years. She passed away prior to our moving into this new home.

In all those years we never visited friends and imposed our pet on them as a condition of our visit. My wife is inclined to let them bring the dog. Am I overly concerned, since this will be a precedent-setter?

What to Do?

DEAR WTD: I agree with you that whatever choice you make will be a precedent-setter. After your daughter moves to his city to be with her boyfriend, this dog may, in fact, become “their” dog.

I am a dog lover, and I have had long-term visitors bring their dogs without incident.

And then there was the episode with the mini-dachshunds. Those two little critters (but mainly their owner) more or less tainted the concept, along with the rugs.

My point is that dogs are as varied as people are. But you don’t know this dog. And at least one member of your family (you) would be quite unhappy having the dog in your home.

Don’t make this your problem to solve. It is theirs. You should be friendly and firm: “I vote no on having the dog with us. If he needs to cancel his trip, I understand. However, there are kennels in the area and if he brings the dog and kennels him, you can both visit him however often you want to. You can take him to the park and on outings as you scoot around the city.”

If your wife and daughter overrule you, then they will be on the hook. The couple should not expect you and your wife to dog-sit, but should take the dog with them when they visit friends.

DEAR AMY: I agree with your response to “Miserable,” who had become obsessed with an old flame.

I had the same problem with a crush on a co-worker. The more I tried to ignore the feeling, the worse it got.

Finally, I confided in another co-worker who is a close friend of mine. She made a joke about it and him, and then my crush just disappeared. Lesson learned.

Been There

DEAR BEEN THERE: Most obsessions don’t simply go “poof,” but I agree that it is completely possible to recover, if you keep your eye on your core values.

Send questions to or Ask Amy, Chicago Tribune, TT500, 435 N. Michigan Ave., Chicago, IL 60611.

Let’s block ads! (Why?)

Published at Tue, 15 Nov 2016 14:00:43 +0000

comment No comments yet

You can be first to leave a comment

mode_editLeave a response

Your e-mail address will not be published. Also other data will not be shared with third person. Required fields marked as *